Rethinking Wellness

Rethinking Wellness

Share this post

Rethinking Wellness
Rethinking Wellness
Does This Study Really Show Diets Are *Good* for Disordered Eating?

Does This Study Really Show Diets Are *Good* for Disordered Eating?

Plus, the links: RFK Jr. and measles, a "functional" doctor goes full MAHA, unpacking the weight-cycling research, and more

Christy Harrison, MPH, RD's avatar
Christy Harrison, MPH, RD
Mar 05, 2025
∙ Paid
18

Share this post

Rethinking Wellness
Rethinking Wellness
Does This Study Really Show Diets Are *Good* for Disordered Eating?
4
2
Share
Photo by Tamanna Rumee on Unsplash

Welcome to another installment of the Rethinking Wellness link roundup! Here I’m offering a small collection of links from around the internet that are relevant to the conversations we have here, along with some quick takes and occasional deeper dives for paid subscribers.

This time the take/dive is about a recent study that purports to show intentional weight loss doesn’t cause disordered eating and actually “improves” it—and what the science really says.

Links

Here are some pieces that got me thinking in the past few weeks. I found value in all of these, but links are not endorsements of every single detail in the piece or everything the writer ever wrote.

Every 100 Years America Produces a Robert Kennedy Jr (Jessica Grose / NYT)

  • Related: Measles cases are rising in the U.S. Do adults need a vaccine booster? (NPR)

  • Related: A Child Is Dead from Measles (

    Katelyn Jetelina
    )

  • Related: RFK Jr. moves to eliminate public comment on HHS decisions (STAT)

  • Related: With RFK Jr. in charge, supplement makers see chance to cash in (CNN)

What Is Will Cole Really Selling? The “functional” doctor goes full MAHA (

Derek Beres
)

New Yale Study on Post-COVID Vaccine Syndrome: Hold Your Horses! (

Unbiased Science
)

Does This Study REALLY Prove There Is No Harm from Weight Cycling? Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3 (

Ragen Chastain
)

Google Gives Up on Data Voids (

Casey Newton
)

Why Should We Trust Science? (

Matthew Facciani
)

In Case You Missed It

A Wellness Misinformationist Is In Charge of Health Policy. What Now?

Vitamin D and Health Outcomes, Part 2

Blood-Sugar Myths and Intuitive Eating for Diabetes with

Janice Dada, MPH, RDN


Take/Dive: Does This Study Really Show Diets Are *Good* for Disordered Eating?

A recent Novo Nordisk–funded systematic review and meta-analysis purports to show that weight-loss interventions don’t increase the risk of disordered eating, and that if anything they somehow reduce that risk. But the study is deeply flawed and doesn’t justify this claim at all—despite what some science communicators have written recently.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Food Psych Programs, Inc. | Artwork by Tara Jacoby.
Publisher Privacy ∙ Publisher Terms
Substack
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share